WALSH – Pandemic restrictions are no longer useful; end the mandates
“The greatest tyrannies are always perpetuated in the name of the noblest causes.”
– Thomas Paine
By DENIS WALSH
Kamloops City Councillor
I WANT TO EXPRESS my sincere appreciation to Mel Rothenburger for having the courage to post the article ‘FEATURED COMMENT – A night with the untouchables at convoy’s ground zero,’ Feb. 6, 2022 giving us an alternative narrative, as to what is taking place in Ottawa.
In this current climate of intolerance along with the transparent open vendetta against the unvaccinated, I want to thank you Mel for demonstrating a strong belief in the basic principle of free speech and that the free exchange of ideas is fundamental to maintaining a free society.
Don’t abandon people, don’t make them irrelevant, don’t censor people, don’t defame them, in an effort to control ‘the’ message… engage with them.
More and more people, across Canada, are simply fed up with two years of COVID restrictions, whether they are double vaccinated, triple vaxxed or ‘the unvaccinated.’ These diverse groups have joined forces and are questioning the need for mandates and many are supporting the protest and asking for an end to current COVID restrictions.
It does appear the organization of this protest seems to have been inadequate; it simply got much bigger than they could have ever imagined. However, it bothers me and others, that some people are more upset about horns honking 2,000 miles away than they are about the person down the road who lost their job and access to society.
Mandates and passports have literally destroyed lives. Where was the empathy and outrage for what happened to these individuals?
The fact that a health issue may continue to exist is not an excuse for governments to start doubling down on policies that, to date, have been largely ineffective and uneven.
We have been delivered from the more dangerous Delta variant by the milder but more contagious Omicron variant. Before this new, milder variant arrived, Canada was on the path to being a two-tier fear-based society totally dependent on government, which is a concern for most free-thinking people.
The milder Omicron variant could be a game changer; the virus appears to be better at immunizing than the novel vaccines. There are some countries that have already relaxed some of their restrictions and, in the case of Denmark, it is the first country to officially eliminate all restrictions. The game of dominoes has begun.
Overall, I believe the protest has been peaceful. Yes, there have been some troublemakers, but I doubt if there has ever been a protest without outliers who don’t embody the stated goals and message of the organized movement.
There is no such thing as a civil movement where everyone is acting in perfect unison. That type of uniformity is reserved for government organized convoys such as the military, who have the resources and provisions to screen every single member and perform extensive background checks.
Unfortunately, true to form, once the protest took root it became an outlet for the extremes on both sides to dig in and start spinning the message to fit with their own agenda.
Disturbingly, there is a large number of Canadians who have seemingly built their personal identity around being ‘vaccinated,’ and seeing themselves as ‘better’ than the unvaccinated and at times their response can emulate a witch-hunt.
A “witch-hunt” metaphorically means a campaign that is usually directed, by a clear majority, against a person or marginalized group, supposedly to uncover subversive activity, disloyalty, or unpopular views.
If allowed to grow, it can also involve elements of moral panic or mass hysteria. I know these modern day witch hunters will never be appeased till every single person, world-wide, is vaccinated. For the more realistic moderates, once they get past the fear mongering, it is simply a feeling of unease and occasional reaction or condemnation of an isolated but unacceptable event.
The convoy protest has been an opportunity for people in both extreme camps to vent their opposing views and extreme narratives, this is predictable but still unfortunate and we see this demonstrated on TV, radio, in op-ed articles, social media, and in this forum’s comments section.
I do want to say I am personally fed up with the cult-like self-righteousness, censorship, disrespect, discrimination and demonization of the marginalized second class citizens labelled anti-vaxxers. This minority group includes the unvaccinated, anyone with a compromised medical condition and those with immunity from having experienced the dominant Omicron variant.
I am always amazed at the righteousness of those who are okay with labeling those they have never met, grouping them like cattle, taking away their individuality and branding them to discredit them. Marginalization is a shameful tool that I continue to see used day after day by COVID extremists or what I like to call the branch Covidians.
It is time to end mandates and end all restrictions and just accept we will never eradicate this virus. Restrictions are no longer useful. We can learn to live with this virus, we can manage it. Let people self-isolate when they feel the need to, start recommending early treatments, live a healthier lifestyle and take special care of those who really need it.
For those in the most vulnerable of groups — the elderly, the obese and immune compromised — the benefits of vaccination could certainly outweigh the risks of COVID-19 infection, but leave the rest of us alone unless we offer our informed consent.
The Covidians need to lower the rhetoric of condemning and demonizing the unvaccinated and stop calling us anti-vaxxers. Yes, there are some but most of us are simply not willing to take part in a medical experiment, which is what this is.
I agree with Green party leader Sonia Furstenau that there has been a lack of clarity and transparency on the COVID file from our government leaders. There needs to be an independent science table established that can provide clear, evidence-based communication, in order to restore public confidence.
For years we have needed more capacity in our hospitals and better health care models, simply saying it is all COVID is a cop-out. “Vaccine Passports” for a ‘vaccine’ that after some time we see clearly doesn’t prevent transmission or infection, is just one of the dumbest authoritarian concepts I have seen.
It’s clear the intended goal was to coerce or force some of the unvaccinated into getting the jab, but it was not a valid health measure, as the restaurant workers serving your table could be one of the unvaccinated.
I had to sell my coffee shop because I could no longer accept being seen as a leper in my own business by a percentage of fearful misguided customers. The psychological effect of vaccine passports, on the misinformed vaccinated, has been to create mass hysteria and a fear of being in the same room or even near someone who is unvaccinated.
If I ever did have to go into my business, I had to enter unseen by the back door and then stay hidden in the basement, to not jeopardize the financial well-being of the business, which helped support 10 innocent employees and their families. I also couldn’t trust my government or city to not someday mandate me from ever going into my own business, so I was motivated to sell it.
The genetic technology that created these novel vaccines, or what I call an experimental remedy, has redefined our understanding of vaccine efficacy versus vaccine effectiveness.
We now know about some of the documented adverse effects from these novel vaccines. I believe the most egregious step in this declared pandemic is the campaign to vaccinate our children. The benefit of this experimental remedy does not outweigh the risk to our children’s developing immune systems, given the general overall minimal health risk of the Omicron virus. It is not our children’s job to keep adults safe.
It takes a leap of faith, at this early stage, as we don’t know what the long-term safety or long-term effects will be. European Union regulators have warned that “frequent” Covid-19 booster shots could weaken the immune system and may not be feasible.
Nobody should ever be forced to put anything into their bodies they do not want and this is why many of us oppose these mandates, a person’s fundamental right of bodily autonomy is what is being threatened. Where there is risk, there needs to be choice.
Denis Walsh is a business person and Kamloops City councillor. He has been a resident of Kamloops since 1980.
Here is something that maybe Denis should read…although he seems pretty set in his thinking.
This sentence is completely and verifiably false, Denis: “The fact that a health issue may continue to exist is not an excuse for governments to start doubling down on policies that, to date, have been largely ineffective and uneven.” If we can agree that reducing hospitalizations and deaths has been the goal, it’s clear that masking and vaxxing have had excellent results to date. Compare the death rates between Canada, and places like Florida or Texas, which have not stressed those protective measures. Or just check out Covid19tracker.ca and see the difference in numbers between BC and AB. Our health policies have undeniably reduced the level of chaos in healthcare and saved lives.
You are choosing to put personal choice above other values, and we can have a debate about that. Whether or not the restrictions are still justified is another good debate to have. But basing your arguments on false statements invalidates them from the start.
DW you lost me after the first 3 paragraphs.Just get your vaccines and all these mandates would probably be over .
What has been the history of the smallpox vaccine? Crude by today’s standards perhaps but look at the results.
I fully support Denis Walsh. As in the start of Mel’s the article there’s two sides to the Ottawa issue and the focus has always been on the negative …or ‘what makes the best news’. Like the Corona Virus, the articles have been never ending in support of getting your shot. What has been blatently absent, right from the beginning, is a ‘balanced’ view presenting both sides from a scientific perspective. And yes, there are two sides despite what Dr.Bonnie Henry would have you believe. It is time to end the mandate. Graham Strachan
This long column appeals only to emotions. Here’s a short statement of fact: vaccines are safe and save lives.
I am double vaccinated and by this afternoon I will be triple vaccinated. I must be real dumb and stupid. At least I am having second thoughts in regards to the viability of my discernment after reading this latest ode to unvaccinated freedom by DW.
But I DO believe the health professionals. I DO believe them more than the truckers and the anti-vaccine freedom fighter. And yes me too I am tired of the restrictions and of the inconsistencies of the various decrees.
Lastly though we trust the greater authority of the government in regards to what we choose to put in our body. Health Canada is the regulatory body entrusted, albeit unknowingly by millions of Canadians, with decision making in regards to all kind of chemicals going daily into our bodies. Pharmaceuticals, pesticides, food additives, etc. In very many cases the threshold for a chemical going from adequately benign to outright dangerous is very tiny and yet it works. It is called science. I trust science.