SINCLAIR – Is Kamloops finally ready to mobilize for a performing arts centre?

Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre. (Image:

Kamloops Arts Council

I FELT MILDLY stunned and disappointed with news the former Kamloops Daily News (KDN) building would become a parking lot. And I wasn’t the only one.

It’s not that the demolition or parking lot idea was a surprise; based on the majority of reports I’ve seen, it’s time to bid farewell to the KDN building. But after a year of waiting for results from the request for information the City issued last March, I hoped for a more optimistic outcome.

Kathy Sinclair.

Nine proposals were received and reportedly only one was seriously considered — which apparently fell through in the 11th hour. Just a few weeks ago, there was a feeling in the air our city could be on the brink of something big. I was hoping that something would have to do with the arts — perhaps a public-private partnership.

Alas, no, despite Deputy Mayor Arjun Singh assuring us the parking lot is a temporary measure, which is conceivable since it will be a surface lot, not an above-ground parkade. 

So, what proposals were received for the site? We don’t know.

The only proponent who has come forward is the Downtown Neighbourhood Association, which pitched saving the building and retrofitting it into a modified performing arts centre (PAC). That PAC would have been significantly different from the one initially proposed for the site. 

But perhaps we should go back a bit.

After the paper shut down in early 2014, the City purchased the 60,000-square-foot site. It was announced it could be the future home of a new Kamloops PAC.

If a PAC is going to happen at the KDN site — or anywhere — perhaps it’s time for the arts community, the business community and citizens to come together and plan a way forward

Over the next year, a city-led proposal came together, a visionary and ambitious project that included a main theatre with 1,200 seats, a studio theatre with 350 and an underground parkade with 349 stalls. I believe it would have met not only our city’s current needs, but served us well for years to come.

(Full disclosure: I was one of the project’s champions, both personally and as a representative of my organization.)

Was it a perfect proposal? No. Many details still had to be filled in, but the 200-plus-page preliminary business case (still available online at was put together after extensive research and consultation.

Were the consultants brought in to work on the project skilled, experienced and knowledgeable? Yes — without a doubt.

As you’ll recall, the PAC went to referendum in November 2015 — three short weeks after the federal election. The vote was defeated, with 46.26 per cent voting yes and 53.7 per cent voting no. (Voter turnout was just 32 per cent.) A large percentage of yes votes came from South Shore residents.

Would the referendum have passed if the PAC had been proposed for another area of town? Was Kamloops just not ready for a PAC?

Leading up to the referendum, one of the questions I kept hearing was, “Why do we need a performing arts centre when we already have Sagebrush Theatre?”

The Sagebrush is wonderful and we’re fortunate to have it, but it’s filled to capacity. That doesn’t mean every seat in the theatre is filled at every performance — just that, between local user groups and the occasional touring acts performances and rehearsals, it’s booked for 88 per cent of prime dates. It also means when touring performers look to play Kamloops en route to/from Vancouver, Kelowna or Calgary, Kamloops is simply not an option.

Western Canada Theatre hosts most of its productions there, as does the Kamloops Symphony Orchestra. It is also used for school shows. Sagebrush needs upgrades and it’s certainly not within easy walking distance of a pre-show dinner or post-performance beverage — a desirable amenity with economic spin-offs.

Other venue options for acts coming through town? Sandman Centre, which seats 3,500. It works for sports events and large stadium-style rock concerts, but not for a Diana Krall or a Sara Bareilles. It is well known the acoustics are terrible.

The Coast Kamloops Hotel and Conference Centre’s dinner theatre can hold up to 475 people. Then there are several other smaller venues, including churches, The Pavilion, The Rex, St. Andrews on the Square and bars like CJ’s Night Club and the Blue Grotto, where the amount of liquor sold factors into the booking equation. Given the current options, acts like Bareilles, Krall and dance companies simply pass us by.

We have a lot of local talent in this city. The artists of tomorrow — those who will follow in the footsteps of rising stars like Kate Morgan and Bees and the Bare Bones — need opportunities to see live local acts. As do the rest of us.

The Kamloops Arts Council just launched an online survey. One of the questions: “What would improve the arts scene in Kamloops?” Among eight possible multiple-choice responses, so far the top is “a performing-arts centre.”

Kamloops is not too small for a PAC; Revelstoke, with a population of 7,000, has one as does Vernon, which has a population of 40,000. 

A PAC is not an elitist venue. Chances are once we get one, everyone will use it at some point — whether for attending a country music show, a high school graduation, a kids’ performance or the symphony.

As for the “we need to solve the homeless problem before we invest in the arts” argument? Why can’t we do both? The arts are a major employer. According to Stats Canada, in 2014, there were 87,800 B.C. jobs directly related to culture industries. That’s nearly four per cent of the provincial workforce.

If this surface parking lot is indeed to be a temporary measure, perhaps it’s time to mobilize. If a PAC is going to happen in that spot — or anywhere — perhaps it’s time for the arts community, the business community and citizens to come together and plan a way forward.

We had a $5-million pledge on the initial proposed PAC. Other funding is out there and, with the support of a private developer, a PAC could be a reality. Are we ready now, Kamloops?

Kathy Sinclair is the executive director of the Kamloops Arts Council,

About Mel Rothenburger (5766 Articles) is a forum about Kamloops and the world. It has more than one million views. Mel Rothenburger is the former Editor of The Daily News in Kamloops, B.C. (retiring in 2012), and past mayor of Kamloops (1999-2005). At he is the publisher, editor, news editor, city editor, reporter, webmaster, and just about anything else you can think of. He is grateful for the contributions of several local columnists. This blog doesn't require a subscription but gratefully accepts donations to help defray costs.

5 Comments on SINCLAIR – Is Kamloops finally ready to mobilize for a performing arts centre?

  1. I agree, BUT …. I agree, BUT … and furthermore, I agree, BUT.

    Many would have to wonder why do we have any public facilities at all? The naysayers shout down any project proposed at all unless it’s cheaper, smaller, less necessities, built here or built there, and on and on the list goes.

    Good grief, it’s a wonder anything at all ever gets done in this city 😦

    I still say … #KamPacNow!

  2. I am all for a PAC but not through taxation. A community bond perhaps?

  3. With more and more people on fixed incomes and the burden of every day living becoming greater, there is little appetite for an extra tax burden by the City.
    If a PAC is desired, then the plan should be one that is embraced by private investors.
    It is NOT a priority nor is it a necessity for the majority of people, otherwise, the vote would have gone the other way.
    Please invest the time and effort in making a viable business plan in partnership with an investor who can see the return on her/his/their investment.
    I simply cannot see the wisdom in heading downtown, dodging potholes, to attend an event at a PAC paid for by tax dollars that would be better spent on maintaining roadways, sidewalks and sewers.

    • Grouchy 1 // May 5, 2017 at 9:57 AM // Reply

      I agree with what you have to say. Until the arts community is willing to take ownership of their dream, and raise the money to build a PAC on their own, lets just quit talking about it. In Kamloops, it seems , the arts community continually whines, wants, and almost demands that the taxpayer provide the money for Their dreams at the expense of having our roads fixed, and other infrastructure looked after. The city should never have bought the KDN building, they should have let nature take its course, directed by the private sector. All the last rendition of a PAC was is an attempt by Milobar ( and our weak minded councilors ) , knowing that in one way or another, he was finished in civic government, to build a legacy monument to himself. The taxpayers were smart to vote it down.

  4. I would agree with everything said here, and I too discussed and argued for the PAC project.
    These days though, it is unfortunate that the very utterance of the sound “PAC” for many here, is now combined with a bad taste. There would be an over riding feeling of ‘oh, no … not that again’ among a lot of the population. It is, too soon.
    The proposal brought to referendum was for many, too expensive, too much and the return economics of having the facility was poorly advocated for. Add to that “there is no option #2”, removed any chance to consider a possibly less expensive alternative. All voters saw was the 90 million dollar sign. Combining it with the parking structure was a huge mistake.
    This experience has left many in the public unwilling to consider any venture towards a PAC in the short term.
    Let it sit as a parking lot for a year or two, with the City maintaining ownership, not falling for the quick buck of selling it to a developer. Then we can all look at a proposal for a performing arts facility.
    Time heals.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: