EDITORIAL – Removal of statue of Judge Matthew Baillie Begbie misguided

Judge Matthew Baillie Begbie.

An Armchair Mayor editorial by Mel Rothenburger.

HOW FAR should we go in erasing recognition of those who played a role in wrongs and perceived wrongs of the past? At what point does it become tantamount to rewriting history?

Recently, a 16-foot bronze statue of American Civil War General Robert E. Lee was removed from its place of honour high above a street in New Orleans, where it had stood since 1884.

Lee is known as an exceptional soldier and military tactician. He didn’t want the war, nor did he support the secession of the south.

Biographers disagree on whether Lee supported or opposed slavery, though he certainly fought for an unjust cause.

Regardless, his statue is said to have been erected not in defense of slavery but as a tribute to Lee’s military genius and role in reconciliation after the war. Yet it became a symbol of enduring racial injustice in the U.S., and demands to take it down eventually won out.

We have our own version of the Robert E. Lee controversy in B.C. The Law Society of B.C. has agreed to remove a statue of Judge Matthew Baillie Begbie from its lobby in Vancouver at the behest of First Nations because of his role in the Chilcotin War.

The “war” was really an extended skirmish that took place in 1864 after a war chief and his followers brutally slaughtered 20 people, including my great-great-grandfather Donald McLean, who was second in command of the force sent to apprehend them.

Begbie convicted six chiefs of murder, and they were hanged. The convictions and punishment were appropriate given the crimes and the legal system of the day, but over time they became symbolic of injustices by colonial society towards First Nations, the Tsilhquot’n in particular.

The six men who were hanged are now regarded by the Tsilhquot’in as heroic defenders of their territory, though a close examination of the facts paints a much more complicated picture, to say the least. Even a Canadian Press story about the removal of the statue stated that Begbie “wrongfully convicted” the chiefs, which is simply not the case.

Until now, at least, Begbie has been a much-respected figure in B.C. history, but his remarkable career doesn’t matter in the context of the movement to erase reminders of the unpleasant parts of the province’s past. The Law Society says it decided to remove Begbie from the lobby as a way to address “colonial symbolism” and as a commitment to the principles of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.

Even getting rid of his statue isn’t enough for the Tsilquot’in Nation, which wants the provincial government to remove Begbie’s name from all public places.

Presumably, that would include a statue of him in Begbie Square in New Westminister, as well as streets, commemorative plaques, historical markers and changing the names of Sir Matthew Begbie Elementary school in Vancouver and Mount Begbie in the Cariboo, Begbie Creek, Begbie Falls and Begbie Trail.

A couple of years ago, Premier Christy Clark declared the convicted chiefs “fully exonerated.” I happen to disagree with that, but I recognize the need for a broader conversation about how we deal with historical sensitivities.

Surely we can find a way to tell all sides of the story in an appropriate manner and continue the journey towards reconciliation without altering historical fact and eradicating monuments.

About Mel Rothenburger (5766 Articles) is a forum about Kamloops and the world. It has more than one million views. Mel Rothenburger is the former Editor of The Daily News in Kamloops, B.C. (retiring in 2012), and past mayor of Kamloops (1999-2005). At he is the publisher, editor, news editor, city editor, reporter, webmaster, and just about anything else you can think of. He is grateful for the contributions of several local columnists. This blog doesn't require a subscription but gratefully accepts donations to help defray costs.

4 Comments on EDITORIAL – Removal of statue of Judge Matthew Baillie Begbie misguided

  1. Grouchy 1 // June 6, 2017 at 9:02 AM // Reply

    Welcome to 1984 , and New Speak.

  2. Lawrence Beaton // June 5, 2017 at 10:46 AM // Reply

    It is rather amazing how societies or organizations attempt to purify society by removing statues or burning the written word. I might ask are we more liable to remember Judge Begbie or the British Columbia Law Society. As an historian, it is my feeling that we can’t just rewrite history to make it right or politically correct. Even if it means incorrectly stating the facts.

  3. and Mount Begbie, clearly visible from anywhere in or near Revelstoke. You cannot change history by erasing a nameplace.

  4. -Someone should give the public a real good study and report on just what ‘colonial injustice’ is and allow the larger public to come to conclusion on certain pieces of history, which, at present sound like they’re being made on the basis of pseudo-compassionate reasons and reasoning.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: