LATEST

CITY HALL – Mayor calls for audit to reduce waste, increase transparency

(Image: Mel Rothenburger)

Mayor Reid Hamer-Jackson wants an independent forensic audit done of City operations to reduce waste and increase transparency, and he’s challenging any councillors who oppose the audit to explain themselves.

The mayor introduced a notice of motion at last week’s council meeting and sent out a news release today (June 17, 2025) as a follow-up. His motion is expected to come up for debate at next week’s regular meeting.

That’s when councillors will get a chance to talk about Hamer-Jackson’s proposal, assuming one of them seconds the motion.

“We are in seriously challenging financial times,” the mayor said in his news release.

“Citizens are facing record tax increases, and they deserve to know their money is being managed with care, efficiency, and full accountability. This motion is not about assigning blame, it’s about identifying opportunities to improve how we operate, reduce waste, and restore trust in City Hall.”

He added, “If any member of Council opposes this, they should be prepared to explain why they would resist greater transparency and accountability to the very people we were elected to serve.”

Hamer-Jackson wants the audit done by “an accredited third-party organization” with no prior business relationship with the City.

He said the audit should examine such things as unjustified cost overruns, misaligned staffing levels or payroll costs, contracting practices and salary raises for City management “that are not fully transparent or justified.”

Full Text of the Notice of Motion

WHEREAS the residents of Kamloops have expressed growing concerns regarding rising property taxes, cost overruns, and a perceived lack of transparency in municipal operations;

AND WHEREAS it is the responsibility of Council to ensure that public funds are managed with integrity, efficiency, and in the best interest of taxpayers;

AND WHEREAS a full and independent forensic audit is a proven method to identify inefficiencies, systemic issues, and any potential misuse or mismanagement of public resources, and also an effective tool for ensuring maximum efficiencies for the finances of the City;

AND WHEREAS for the purpose of this motion, “inefficiencies or concerning findings” shall include, but not be limited to:

– Unjustified cost overruns or lack of cost control in capital projects;

– Duplicated efforts across departments or unclear responsibilities leading to resource waste;

– Staffing levels or payroll costs not aligned with actual service delivery requirements;

– Contracting practices that lack competitive fairness or transparency;

– Delayed asset maintenance or mismanagement of infrastructure replacement cycles;

– Budgeting or reporting practices that obscure the true financial health of the City;

– Decisions or expenditures that do not reflect value-for-money for taxpayers;

– Salary raises for City management that are not fully transparent at the time they occur or are not accompanied by clear justification or performance rationale;

THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT Council direct staff to initiate a Request for Proposals (RFP) for a third-party forensic audit of all City of Kamloops departments and management practices;

AND THAT the scope of the audit include, but not be limited to:

– Financial controls and accounting practices;

– Procurement and contracting procedures;

– Staffing and payroll practices;

– Hiring practices within City Hall;

– Departmental budgeting and project delivery;

– Evaluation of staffing levels across departments to ensure alignment with actual service delivery requirements and community needs;

– Assessment of asset management practices to ensure they meet or exceed recognized industry standards for maintenance, renewal, and long-term infrastructure planning;

– Overall operational efficiency and governance practices;

AND THAT this audit process be implemented at the earliest possible convenience;

AND THAT any third-party organization considered for this work must:

a) Be fully accredited and qualified to conduct forensic audits of this nature; and

b) Have no prior or existing contracts or business relationships with the City of Kamloops to ensure full independence and impartiality;

AND FURTHER THAT while we acknowledge that undertaking such a comprehensive audit will come at a financial cost to the corporation, we believe the long-term benefits will strengthen the organization, reinforce fiscal responsibility, and help restore and retain the full trust of the community;

AND THAT I see no reason why any member of this Council would hesitate to support this motion, as I believe each of you shares the same commitment to transparency, accountability, and good governance;

AND THAT, as outlined in the Community Charter, we are accountable to the public — our employers — and they deserve full confidence in how decisions are made and how their tax dollars are managed within these walls.

Respectfully submitted,

Mayor Reid Hamer-Jackson

Mel Rothenburger's avatar
About Mel Rothenburger (11572 Articles)
ArmchairMayor.ca is a forum about Kamloops and the world. It has more than one million views. Mel Rothenburger is the former Editor of The Daily News in Kamloops, B.C. (retiring in 2012), and past mayor of Kamloops (1999-2005). At ArmchairMayor.ca he is the publisher, editor, news editor, city editor, reporter, webmaster, and just about anything else you can think of. He is grateful for the contributions of several local columnists. This blog doesn't require a subscription but gratefully accepts donations to help defray costs.

10 Comments on CITY HALL – Mayor calls for audit to reduce waste, increase transparency

  1. If there is anyone out there who’s willing to wager a bet that this council will pass this motion, please contact me personally. I will take on all bets for any size wager you feel comfortable with, at any odds that you would like to set, no questions asked. 10 to 1, no problem. 100 to 1, sure thing. 1 million to 1, you drive a hard bargain, call me krazy but I’ll take that bet.

    Have I got your attention now? As an added prize for the first person who takes me up on this offer I’ll throw in a brand new Cadillac Eldorado, for the runner up, a set of steak knives.

    Like

  2. I don’t think it’s healthy that the current councillors seem to have given themselves absolute control over open consultation and debate. Too many closed meetings, no public inquiry, a consistent refusal to second any of the mayor’s motions, etc.
    At this point, I just wish the councillors would decide to honour the basics of democracy and at least get the topic on the table. It could be any issue. If need be, they can always vote it down after discussion.
    Besides, a forensic audit is worth open public debate. Many taxpayers have questions about the Northbridge Hotel deal, for instance–how did the City end up spending so much on a vacant lot worth a fraction of the cost? There are other City land deals that could probably benefit from some transparency, too.
    A forensic audit is a deep dive into both the patterns and minutiae of expenditures. It doesn’t have to be for finding fraud, although that happens, as with the TNRD recently. A forensic audit can reveal ways to reduce waste and optimize income. It could be very helpful, especially now that Kamloops taxpayers are on the cusp of incurring half a $billion in loans for the PAC, arenas and RCMP HQ.

    Like

  3. Also to be “audited” or at least seriously questioned is that the taxpayers are saddled with large infrastructure costs upgrades and with large tax “holidays” for selected developments. In the meanwhile the “investors” behind those selected developments reap huge profits. I don’t think that’s fair.

    Like

  4. this is a ridiculous proposal and clearly written to causes as much embarrassment as possible to the Councillors. It is far too broad to be viable, and would cost a fortune to implement. It is just petty and will do nothing to improve trlations around the table

    Like

  5. Unknown's avatar Quebec Nordiques // June 18, 2025 at 9:52 AM // Reply

    What’s another few hundred million dollar AAP amongst friends, John?

    Like

    • Unknown's avatar John Noakes // June 18, 2025 at 3:18 PM // Reply

      Mais oui, mon ami!

      But yes, my friend! Indeed, as Councillor Katie said, we pensioners and other citizens need to get our heads out of the sand, the weeds. (That’s a good place to lose one’s hairpiece or mess up an expensive perm.)

      It sounds like the taxpayers are the problem.

      Like

  6. Unknown's avatar Quebec Nordiques // June 18, 2025 at 7:03 AM // Reply

    Can I get a seconder? No? Ok then thank you.

    Like

  7. Unknown's avatar John Noakes // June 18, 2025 at 6:59 AM // Reply

    Good for you, Mayor Hamer-Jackson.

    Just yesterday, did the citizens of Kamloops not receive the news that our water treatment plant is running close to capacity and further restrictions on water use may come into effect?  If not, then “we” are looking at some major expense to increase the capacity for potable water in Kamloops.

    Meanwhile, we are about to face another AAP (or two) in order that a lot more money can be borrowed to build a new RCMP HQ building plus some other incidental expenses amounting to millions of dollars.

    The AAPs for the PAC and arena complex will allow the borrowing of a big sum of money.  Without the issue of the present water treatment capacity, it appears taxpayers are going to be on the hook for about half a billion dollars……correct me if I am wrong. 

    A number of seniors are barely surviving if they are trying to keep a family home.  The half billion extra of borrowed money transferred to property taxes should prove interesting to seniors.

    Will the original chair of Build Kamloops be back at the helm before the end of this council term?

    Again I say, good for you, Mayor Hamer-Jackson.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Anyone paying a little attention to the way the City operates would fully support an audit as proposed by the mayor.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Unknown's avatar Clint Price // June 17, 2025 at 9:49 PM // Reply

    I wonder if such an audit wouid reveal if sewer and water upgrades will be foisted off on taxpayers who do not have access to city water and sewer. Also if the city is talking about water flows on the Fraser at Hope, and the subsequent reduction on our water usage to help in the crisis, including the pulp mill would be fair. It is hard to find the numbers but it uses an incredible amount of water.

    Like

Leave a reply to Pierre Cancel reply