LATEST

EDITORIAL – We have lost a man of many words and unremitting patriotism

Rex Murphy. (Image: CBC)

An editorial by Mel Rothenburger.

MANY’S THE TIME, as I struggle to express myself on the issues of the day, or even in the throes of somnambulant tranquility, that I wish I had the literary and intellectual capacity of Rex Murphy.

In my view, he was a genius of unambiguous singularity, a juggernaut of fearless reason. Never a man of tattered platitudes or flaccid nothing-burger declarations, he was, to the core, a true and unflinching Canadian.

Throughout his 77 years, Rex Murphy railed against the malignancy of political cowardice and phony wokeness, standing strong against the misdirected correctness of those who insist on self-flagellating themselves over the alleged short-comings of his beloved Canada.

He shared his welcome wisdom with us on his CBC Point of View editorials — which were always much anticipated and awaited on The National — Cross Country Checkup and more recently via the National Post.

His gift was in the way he connected words we seldom use in everyday conversation, in order to bring into deliciously sharp focus the issues of our time. Those words weren’t necessarily foreign to us, and not necessarily long either, but they were always like the third bowl of porridge in Goldilocks and the Three Bears — just right.

For defending our country against persistent allegations of systemic racism (his sin was to declare, “Most Canadians, the vast majority in fact, are horrified and would never participate in it. We are in fact not a racist country.”) he was almost banished from the national conversation.

But he and his brand of unremitting candor and steadfast faith in the great national mosaic would not be silenced by, as he called them, the “great catalogue of phobes.”

Rex Murphy was comfortable in his own skin, which must have been the thickness of a hard-cover print-edition Thesaurus, but he appreciated the limitations of his craft.

“Everything written,” he once stated, “if it has anything in it, will offend someone, and if the mere taking of offence was to amount to a licence to kill the offender, well the world would be sadly underpopulated of novelists, columnist, bloggers, and the writers of editorials.”

Right to the end, he wrote, and pontificated, and challenged, and faithfully filed his last columns with the National Post even as the evil ravages of cancer overtook him and, in an act of unparalleled injustice, finally silenced him.

There will never be another like Rex Murphy to tear asunder our frailties and mine so deep into the national soul. With his passing, we are unpopulated by a writer who unflinchingly wielded a scalpel on the fabric of our country’s infirmities, and for whom we’ll be eternally grateful.

Mel Rothenburger is a regular contributor to CFJC Today, publishes the ArmchairMayor.ca opinion website, and is a recipient of the Jack Webster Foundation Lifetime Achievement Award. He has served as mayor of Kamloops, school board chair and TNRD director, and is a retired daily newspaper editor.  He can be reached at mrothenburger@armchairmayor.ca.

Mel Rothenburger's avatar
About Mel Rothenburger (11741 Articles)
ArmchairMayor.ca is a forum about Kamloops and the world. It has more than one million views. Mel Rothenburger is the former Editor of The Daily News in Kamloops, B.C. (retiring in 2012), and past mayor of Kamloops (1999-2005). At ArmchairMayor.ca he is the publisher, editor, news editor, city editor, reporter, webmaster, and just about anything else you can think of. He is grateful for the contributions of several local columnists. This blog doesn't require a subscription but gratefully accepts donations to help defray costs.

9 Comments on EDITORIAL – We have lost a man of many words and unremitting patriotism

  1. Unknown's avatar Janet Michael // June 10, 2024 at 4:29 AM // Reply

    Regarding Rex Murphy. I knew Rex. I attended Memorial University of Newfoundland when he was there. Rex was much admired by me as an intellect and wordsmith. But I have to say that his sweeping declarations of a racist free Canada scream bigotry and social ignorance.

    Rex had an intellectual gift but was socially disabled. His eyes never came off the page. He had no idea how people of racial minorities in Canada have had to struggle with descrimination. He constructed a vision of Canada that suited his own personal biases.

    Remember, Newfoundlanders took care of the “Indian problem” with rifles and knives and nooses and got paid for scalps. The ‘Canada’ Rex grew up in had one Indigenous People, the Beothuk, and it’s extinct.

    Janet Michael

    Like

  2. Unknown's avatar Ken McClelland // May 11, 2024 at 4:29 PM // Reply

    Rex was one of my favorite columnists, period. I always looked forward to reading his pieces, even if I didn’t necessarily agree (although I usually did…). I will miss him greatly.

    Like

  3. Unknown's avatar Walter Trkla // May 11, 2024 at 3:31 PM // Reply

    In order to have ethical politicians we need ethical journalists. Was Rex an ethical journalist? All my life I was accountable and legally responsible to the code of ethics of my craft. I had a moral responsibility to be truthful because the future of my community depended on me to be accountable, ethical and truthful. I had to use natural justice and be fair and impartial in dealing with my clients. I had to provide evidence-based information that was independently verifiable and if I failed to meet these standards, I would have lost my job or even gone to jail for my malfeasance.

     I worked under a legal and social framework, that encourages all of us in our craft to respect and follow the established values and norms that society expected. We must hold politicians, journalists, and traditional media to the same standard that will provide ethical leadership and freedom of expression. The law should hold journalism accountable not only for what they say but also for what they omit.    

    I would hope that the news in the Media will not be manufactured at some computer by armchair columnists or editors who are fed information in reports produced thousands of miles away. These reports represent someone else’s reality which does not dare rock the boat of the agenda makers. Its these editorials and columns that reach the man on the street, a reprinted false version of the reality, that the agenda makers intended to reach the street level.

     Those who paraphrase official reports lie, either because they are intellectually lazy or brainwashed by what CNN, CBC, or BBC report. These reports, are seldom from the trenches but almost always from the comfort of a friendly NATO base or from friendly terrorists with their own agenda that journalists ignore.  

    This reporting are lies by omission ignore the truth, as conspiracy theories in order to get paid. How can an editor justify writing about events when there is not a single journalist in the West on the Muslim side in Palestine and the ones that are always qualify the death of thousands of Muslim children by the Holocaust done by the Christins. Do the Russians and Iraqis and Afghanis not have families that we blow up with our drones and jets? Do they not have homes that our soldiers bomb into smithereens? Why not tell the reader how Ukraine, Iraq, Afghanistan and Palestine happened.

    How can an editor dismiss firsthand accounts of defense attorneys about Rwanda, court transcripts, evidence of falsification of faxes by our own people to the UN as conspiracy theories? On the basis of this evidence the reality that the editor or journalist was fed is no longer true but the editors defend it, not with evidence of his own but with a dismissal that the evidence provided in a Court is conspiratorial.  These editors and journalists hang onto the false reality that has shaped their columns and editorial pages, thus anything different is a conspiracy.        

    A reporter or a columnist does not need to agree with me but he or she must take a side and defend that side with honest and verifiable evidence that can be defended. If he or she does not do that they cause more harm than a common thief who steals to eat. We need to ask the editors and journalists if the three political parties in Ottawa serve the Canadian national interest?

    Those who get close to the truths and print it either die or lose their job or are never quoted. All of you who publish anything against our own interest, against the interest of NATO, against the interest of globalization or corporatism you will be marginalize. Not only that, you will be fired and unfortunately you will be all alone in this real world that you have created and believed in which has now abandoned you for telling the truth.

    This real world that you have served is at a brink of being destroyed and all of us in it. It’s not Cuban missile crisis where two nations stared down one another, today its global annihilation in the hands of former colonizers, war mongers, economic blackmailers, religious zealots who for several centuries have enslaved others that have their finger on the thermonuclear button and editors are silent.

    When editors and journalists tell us that the Greens are the problem in BC politics, how can that be since they love the world more than the ones who wish to destroy it for profit. How can an editor write and publish columns to support sanctions, tribunals, arms sales, military industrial complex, wars, and demonization of people and nations when they only listen to one side?  They have not verified why we are a party to this waste, nevertheless, they continue to support it? Editorial participation and support for brutalization and slander by those who want to make all of us into drones ignore reality and value trivial, promoted by manipulated mindless information about the world where few decide who lives and who dies. They want mindless workers rather than thinking people who want progress, compassion, positivity and peace.  

    Like

    • Unknown's avatar Mel Rothenburger // May 11, 2024 at 5:45 PM // Reply

      Uh huh. So what did you think of Rex?

      Like

      • Unknown's avatar Walter Trkla // May 11, 2024 at 6:16 PM //

        He was part of everything I said. If he had said what Assange and Hersch said he would not be celebrated as a journalist

        Like

    • Not exactly a eulogy but in Canada, we do have freedom of speech.

      Like

      • Unknown's avatar Walter Trkla // May 12, 2024 at 9:03 AM //

        Rex was a skilled writer, a conservative pundit, in death praised by Harper, Poilievre and Conrad Black. The greatest sin of a journalist is to manipulate information by omission and exclude in their journalism what they know needs to be debated. What Rex did and what many journalists do they excused the negative as done with good intentions regardless of how many died and who benefited.

        I don’t agree with many views coming from Harper, Poilievre and Conrad Black but I defend their right to say them since “in Canada, we do have freedom of speech” beyond a eulogy and I would suggest reserved more for some than others.

        Recent articles, two examples, by Rex Murphy “Hatred of Israel is the great moral disorder of our time” Link:  https://nationalpost.com/opinion/rex-murphy-hatred-of-israel-is-the-great-moral-disorder-of-our-timeand a critique of his position on racism reflects his historical blindness on many issues Link:https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/tbs-sct/documents/living-digital/20210623-LD-article-response-e.pdf

        Many Jews will disagree with Rex in what he wrote on Palestine.  There is huge amount of evidence on the Jewish question which Rex omits, space and time do not allow for me to provide evidence based verifiable facts on the Middle East so that the   reader can constructively, independently, and without external controls find his/her own answer. On Racism there is ample evidence in our own community and in the past, I have written articles on this issue and I will leave it at that.   Link:  http://www.swans.com/library/art16/wtrkla04.html

        Rex was a great writer who spoke to our emotions which is divisive and just because Mel liked him it does not mean he needs to be eulogized as an icon of Canadian values which for many he was not.

        Like

  4. The most Rex sounding you have ever been Mel …
    a lost voice to be sure. Hopefully someone will fill the void.

    Like

  5. Beautiful tribute, Mel! As a nation, we are all the poorer for the passing of Rex. His unique voice in the public square, his wisdom and wit were the cornerstone of our collective conscience. And now he’s gone… May he rest in peace.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Mel Rothenburger Cancel reply