Where’s local leadership on the economy issue?
Today’s We Say editorial in The Daily News takes a strip off municipal politicians and they deserve it.
“Kamloops City Council, as well as candidates in the current civic election campaign, are missing in action on what promises to be the most important upcoming challenge to the community,” the editorial says. “The slowing economy should be front and centre at council meetings as well as candidates’ forums, but it is not.”
It says the current council has been asleep at the switch on the issue, apparently hoping it will go away. Candidates — veterans and newbies alike — haven’t come to the table with any significant ideas during the civic election campaign, either.
Mayoral candidate Peter Milobar has taken a Stephen Harperesque stay-the-course-and-don’t-screw-it-up approach. Murphy Kennedy challenges that approach but while he’s announced several policy ideas, none of them involves a comprehensive strategy on dealing with the sliding economy. Brian Alexander, likewise.
The editorial proposes a task force be called together immediately, one that would include homebuilders, realtors, manufacturers, the chamber of commerce, business improvement groups, industry, labour and retailers.
What could a task force do? What can we do locally about an economy that is determined by global factors?
In my view, a task force could, first of all, analyze the expectations for the Kamloops economy — what’s going to happen with jobs, consumer spending, housing prices, local investment capital, and so on. Secondly, it could agree on a strategy aimed at reducing the negative impacts on the local economy — a new marketing plan for the city, a buy-local campaign, business-attraction, a municipal tax-reduction strategy, for example.
First and foremost, how can we promote the Kamloops advantage — set ourselves apart from the others, and make it clear that our city remains a great place to live and work?
Many ideas might come forward that would prove impractical; many might be doable. We can rest on our laurels and talk about all the fine things we’re already doing, or we can recognize that a special challenge is heading our way and determine to take special measures.
Point is, civic leaders are supposed to lead. They’re supposed to come up with ideas. A large part of being a civic politician involves bringing people together. The fact that so little has been done on the economy issue during the past several weeks in council chambers or during the current election campaign suggests leadership might be in shorter supply than we’d like.
Generally speaking, I have a different view from the editorial and from this post. Far from being asleep at the switch, many many council candidates have talked about needing to address a slowing, perhaps soon freefalling, economy.
It really happened so quickly. Specific ideas have yet to emerge as to addressing the issue. Even two months ago, it was not really so much on the radar. Now, I feel, once the new council is elected, helping to address the slowing economy will be a priority issue. I think the idea of a task force is a reasonable thing to discuss.
LikeLike
Mel,
I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree on whether or not people reading my website would understand whether or not I was talking about a group of people working together or individual stakeholder group meetings.
I assumed they would but you know what they say when you assume something .
Murphy I agree that a good idea is a good idea and it shouldn’t matter where it comes from. I’m confused though, it seems that your new number one priority for council is nowhere in your 26 page platform.
My confusion is this. I know for a fact that Mel was Mayor as I was a Councillor during one of his terms. This would make him a former Mayor. Seems like your new top priority is the vision of a former Mayor?
Seems kind of contradictory doesn’t it ?
Peter
LikeLike
Hi Mel:
Good editorial as it gets people thinking. However, I do take a bit of umbrage with your reference to no action being taken by the candidates. On my business platform, while not calling it a task force, I have been stating that we need to put a plan in place: A plan that recognizes the need for sound and wise management of the current economic situation while also recognizing the need for a recovery plan: Buy local to keep as much money in our economy as possible: Recognition that Venture Kamloops needs to be supported: I talk about setting ourselves apart by becoming a specialist and one or two fields: I talk about leveraging TRU as a business incubator asset that could put us miles ahead of anyone: I talk about rethinking the agricultural business. And I understand and state that leadership is needed with concrete ideas and a full understanding of how our economy works.
It’s interesting to note that during last week’s business forum, many of the questions were focused on environmental issues as opposed to economic concerns. The North Shore forum wasn’t heavy on economic issues either and when ideas were put on the table, the reaction was less then overwhelming. Yet the most visited page on my blog is and remains, the Business Platform page. Perhaps there just isn’t the time in 60-second forum bites to give the economy the time and attention it needs.
Is it a lack of ideas, a shortage of leadership or is there still that faint-hope clause suggesting an economic reprieve is still somehow out there?
LikeLike
Mel,
I completely agree with this idea, and it is needed right away. I would say this even if I wasn’t running for Mayor – it ‘s just plain common sense. We all know this economic storm is going to be severe, and is now on our doorstep, and to not take decisive action would be irresponsible.
I’m sure all candidates, including me, wish this was their idea. I agree that this should be the new mayor and council’s top prority: it will be mine. It doesn’t matter whose idea it was…it’s a good one.
Murphy
LikeLike
I commend you for committing to work cooperatively with local agencies. But you are right, there’s a difference between that and a task force that would bring everyone to the same table to develop a community strategy. Without the leadership to bring everyone together, the issue remains just another agenda item or addendum to discussions within individual groups of stakeholders. Mel.
LikeLike
Hi Mel, if you were to look at my website, petermilobar.com, you would see that under both the vision and commitment tabs I have mentioned exactly what is in the paper and your post. I also closed the downtown fourm on Friday with comments stating the same. Michelle was there so you can check with her. My point is, I have been talking about working together from day one. I guess I could call it a task force but I chose not to. See you Wednesday.
Peter Milobar
LikeLike